Tale of the Tape: McKie vs. Barnes - SCACCHoops.com

Tale of the Tape: McKie vs. Barnes

   Posted by Blogger So Dear at  1/31/2012 1:56:41 PM  |  Follow us on Twitter: @scacchoops
Discuss     Bookmark and Share

Coming into Wake's big time game against UNC tonight, I decided I'd run a special feature matching up 2 players, one from each team, and comparing and contrasting them. The most natural matchup that occurred to me was Wake's Travis McKie vs. UNC's Harrison Barnes, so that's the matchup we're going to look at in this feature. Everything from size to stats will be looked at in this feature.


Gerry Broome - AP


McKie: 6'7"/210

Barnes: 6'8"/215

Edge: Barnes, but barely. There's not much of a difference here.



McKie: 16.3

Barnes: 17.5

Edge: Again, Barnes, but barely, and this is particularly interesting given another stat I'll get into later.



McKie: 7.1

Barnes: 4.6

Edge: McKie by a healthy margin on the boards. Of course, UNC has more of a front line so it might be deceptive, but it is indeed possible that McKie is more of a board-crasher in general than Barnes.



McKie: 14.5%

Barnes: 10.1%

Edge: Healthy edge to McKie percentage-wise, as well.



McKie: 8.9%

Barnes: 7.2%

Edge: Again, the edge goes to McKie.



McKie: 1.1

Barnes: 1.0

Edge: Virtually even, though McKie has the smallest edge possible here.



McKie: 14

Barnes: 8

Edge: McKie



McKie: 47.5% on 261 attempts

Barnes: 49.1% on 271 attempts

Edge: Slight edge to Barnes here.



McKie: 34,9% on 63 attempts

Barnes: 45% on 60 attempts

Edge: Healthy edge to Barnes on this one.



McKie: 51.7%

Barnes: 54.1%

Edge: Slight edge to Barnes here. Without that 1-13 game, the edge would probably go to Travis.



McKie: 70.6% on 102 attempts

Barnes: 73,5% on 102 attempts

Edge: Barnes by a little, though it's fascinating to me that they've taken exactly the same number of free throws. For the record, the difference in percentage is a measly 3 makes.



McKie; 34.7 minutes

Barnes: 26.3 minutes

Edge: McKie gets significantly more minutes. This is worth considering when you factor things like number of shot attempts, but I'll get to that.



McKie: 25.5%

Barnes: 26.5%

Edge: Barnes gets used even more than McKie, which is interesting to me particularly because McKie gets significantly more minutes, so you'd think it would be the other way around. However, it's a very slight difference regardless.



Statistically, when you put everything together and factor it all in, it's almost eerie. McKie and Barnes are, in most ways, virtually identical players. McKie seems to be a more "blue-collar" player with more rebounds (by a large margin) and blocks, while Barnes is significantly more of a threat outside. All considered, though, everything is so close in most other categories, they're virtually interchangeable. If we were in bizarro world and Barnes was a Deac and McKie was a Tar Heel, if the pure stats are anything to go by, there probably wouldn't be a particularly significant difference in the standings of the teams.

I was actually surprised how similar these two are. We've seen it before, but it'll definitely be cool to see these two amazing players battle again on the court.

As always, comments encouraged and appreciated. Go Deacs.

This article was originally published at http://www.BloggerSoDear.com. If you are interested in sharing your website's content with SCACCHoops.com, Contact Us.


Post a Comment About this Article
Entry Link     3 Comment(s)

dude   (Not Registered)
some strong analysis, not really though - 1/31/2012 4:32:57 PM - Login Verification: None

Here's the reasons they don't compare:

McKie is one of two players capable of generating any offense for Wake. Barnes is one of 5 or 6.

The difference in minutes per game is heavily discounted in this analysis. Let's assume that they both score 17 ppg. That means Barnes scores .65 pts/min, while McKie only scores .49 pts/min. So given McKie's minutes, Barnes would average 22.5 ppg, significantly more than McKie's ppg. Applying this method to other stats like rebounding and assists helps show a more accurate picture. Yes, McKie is still a better blocker and rebounder, but not by as much as you'd have us think.

Anyway, I know you Wake fans are having a pretty bad season and are looking for some silver lining, so I won't stomp on your dreams further.

Here's to a good competitive game. Go Heels!

WebMaster   (685 post(s) - All-Conference)
At half - 1/31/2012 9:02:53 PM - Login Verification: SCACCHoops

Comparing at halftime, all Barnes

McKie 0 pts, 8 rebs

Barnes 7 pts, 5 rebs

bobboone   (Not Registered)
LOL - 3/9/2012 4:09:06 PM - Login Verification: None

That was the dumbest analysis I have ever seen.  If Barnes played for Wake, they would have made the NCAA tournament.  Maybe McKie can get a job as a limo driver for Barnes in a couple of seasons.

Post a Comment

Posting As:   Remember Me?

Before submitting this form, please type the color of the second character:

Should the ACC change their FB divs to setup a potential FSU/Clemson title game?
Dont Care

Game Sim's college football week 10 predictions
10/30/2014 8:45:47 AM
Backlash for the perceived SEC Bias from ESPN is real and growing
10/30/2014 6:33:29 AM
FSU Practices On The Great Lawn, Leaves After Media Shows Up
10/29/2014 8:15:28 PM
ACC Media Day 2014: Syracuse Videos, Interviews, etc
10/29/2014 8:14:35 PM
Duke picked ACC preseason favorite; Paige, Okafor claim honors
10/29/2014 4:06:03 PM
The game Louisville fans haven't been able to stop thinking about is finally here
10/29/2014 12:29:17 PM
Pat Forde Picks the Wrong UNC Player to Make an Academic Joke About
10/29/2014 12:28:29 PM
Pitt down but not out in the mediocre ACC Coastal Division
10/29/2014 12:27:05 PM
2014-15 Pittsburgh Panthers Basketball Preview
10/29/2014 9:02:11 AM
Watch the 2014 ACC Men's Basketball Media Day Live
10/29/2014 7:38:07 AM
2014 ACC Hoops Preview: Returners by "Impact Score"
10/29/2014 6:20:19 AM
College Football Playoff Rankings Released; 4 ACC Teams represented
10/28/2014 7:09:41 PM
Articles from around the ACC Blogosphere 10/28
10/28/2014 6:08:57 AM
ACC Announces Football Players of the Week for October 27
10/27/2014 12:29:15 PM
Will's Week Nine Rankings
10/27/2014 9:45:30 AM
Message Board
YBN Widget
RSS Feed  
SCACC Hoops has no affiliation to the NCAA or the ACC
Team logos are trademarks of their respective organizations (more/credits)