Because of the quick turnaround between the final game of the season and the All-ACC ballots being due, you have to start this legwork early. This is my exercise at getting the list of candidates to a manageable number.
My basic criteria were
1. Offensive rating for the season over 100
2. Used in more than 20% of their team's possessions
3. Played at least 25 minutes per game
That gave me 26 players and I added three because of special circumstances.
Kendall Marshall - Best passer in the league. Fell short of usage % criteria.
Jontel Evans - Best perimeter defender in the league. Fell short of offensive rating criteria.
Scott Wood - Most efficient offensive player in the league. Fell short of usage % criteria.
That gives me 29 names to parse through over the next 10 days. Here they are, by school.